What if I have a shake roof? What should I replace it with today?
July 26, 2010
What if I have a shake roof? What should I replace it with today?
This is another great question. Here are more questions that if you can answer will help your sales person propose the right material for your home:
1. What are your plans for the home? Are you planning to sell soon? If not, how long are you planning on living in this home?
2. Do have Home Owner Association’s CC&R’s (Codes, Covenants and Restrictions) that call for a certain type or quality of shingle or shake?
3. Do you want to go from a shake roof to a shingle roof?
If you can answer these questions you will get a better more precise answer to your questions and your desires.
Most CC&R’s will spell out the type of roof you can have. A number of them have limits to either roofing tiles or shake roofs. These limitations were placed on homes built in the 1970’s 1980’s and 1990’s when asphalt shingles were three tab style and not very appealing. Today, this has changed.
One reason for this change is the quality of the raw cedar has changed a good deal. The high quality shakes that were generally available 30 years ago are still on the market, but they are much more expensive and much harder to find. The current general quality shake is of a much lower standard. Shakes also require more maintenance. Additionally, most real estate inspectors do not understand what makes a good shake roof. So when a sale inspection is necessary they will error on the conservative side and tell you it is time to replace the shakes.
So, what to do? The shakes are almost always on skip sheathing. It is 1” x 6” lumber spaced to accommodate the shake spacing. So, if you remove the shakes you can either replace them with more shakes or you can solid plywood on over the skip sheathing and install an asphalt shingle.
The asphalt shingles today come in many shapes, thickness, colors and warranty options. Many HOA’s now allow a 40 year architectural laminate shingle, such as CertainTeed Presidential in place of the shakes. These are great products. They have been in the marketplace a long time with great results. Several other manufactures such as GAF, Malarkey, Owens Corning and others make similar products.
If you are in the market for a new roof on your home I would recommend calling us first, OF COURSE, but in reality many roofing contractors install these products and they are good quality installers.
These are always tried and true products. Use a trusted contractor who has been in the business for 10 years or more. Most roofing contractors who have been in the industry this long know which products work and which ones don’t! Asking the right questions will guarantee quality results. Good luck.











